Skip to content

Quebec (Attorney General) v. SGS Canada inc.

On appeal from the Quebec Court of Appeal

Judgment released
November 6, 2026
Appeal heard
December 2, 2025Watch the hearing
Citation
2026 SCC 37
Docket
41334
Disposition
Appeal dismissed

Themes

Panel

In brief

The Supreme Court, by a majority, held that the labour relations of the 14 inspectors and graders in SGS’s Montréal Branch fall within derivative federal jurisdiction and that the Quebec Labour Code does not apply to them; four judges dissented.

Solon on this page

Solon answers with the context of this page. It comes with a subscription: sign in to get started.

Sign in

Summary of the reasons

Reasons of Karakatsanis J.

paras. 1–122

Karakatsanis J. says the appeal concerns the limited circumstances in which Parliament may regulate employees working in connection with federal works, despite the provincial presumption over labour relations. The 14 inspectors and graders at SGS’s Montréal Branch principally service six grain elevators declared federal works under s. 92(10)(c) of the Constitution Act, 1867. Applying Tessier, the Court must identify the entity, determine whether a unit is functionally distinct, and then assess direct or derivative jurisdiction. Direct jurisdiction concerns an entity operating the federal work; derivative jurisdiction concerns a third party whose vital or integral services are significant to it. The Branch is functionally distinct and devotes 90 percent of its services to the elevators. Because SGS does not operate them, jurisdiction is derivative. The Quebec Labour Code is therefore inapplicable, and the appeal should be dismissed.

I. Background

paras. 10–22
A. The Regulation of Grain Elevators and Grain Inspection Under the Canada Grain Act
paras. 10–22

The Canadian Grain Commission regulates grain inspection and grading under the Canada Grain Act. Grain elevators receive, process, store and ship grain, and are declared works for the general advantage of Canada under s. 55(1). Since 2012, the Commission inspects export grain, while authorized third parties inspect grain for interprovincial trade. SGS is one such provider. Its Agriculture and Agri-Food Division, the company’s only agriculture division, performs most testing in the Canadian grain market through eight branches, including Montréal. The Division samples, inspects, grades and weighs grain, issues certificates and facilitates domestic and international trade. The proposed unit comprises 14 inspectors and graders. The Montréal Branch operates independently, spends more than 90 percent of its time serving six Quebec grain elevators, chiefly Viterra, and performs most work at clients’ facilities. The balance concerns companies facilitating international trade.

II. Judgments Below

paras. 23–27
A. Tribunal Decision, 2021 QCTAT 1021 (Administrative Judge Paquette)
paras. 23–24

The union applied under the Quebec Labour Code to certify the 14 inspectors and graders. The Administrative Labour Tribunal dismissed the application, holding that their labour relations were not provincial. Direct federal jurisdiction did not apply because SGS did not operate the elevators. The Tribunal found derivative federal jurisdiction: the Agriculture and Agri-Food Division was functionally separate from SGS’s other operations, and its Quebec activities were integral to the six federal grain elevators along the St. Lawrence River.

B. Superior Court Decision, 2023 QCCS 1186 (Dufour J.)
paras. 25–26

The Superior Court dismissed the application for judicial review and upheld derivative federal jurisdiction. It held that the Tribunal’s findings about the Division’s distinctive functions and operations in Quebec sufficiently established that the Montréal Branch was functionally distinct from SGS. Although the Tribunal had erred by failing to identify one federal undertaking as the focus of its analysis, that error was not fatal because its findings also addressed the Branch’s integration into Viterra’s grain elevator.

C. Court of Appeal Decision, 2024 QCCA 460 (Schrager, Mainville and Hamilton JJ.A.)
para. 27

The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal and upheld federal regulation. It found no error in the Tribunal’s assessment of the Branch’s essential nature or in considering the Branch separately from SGS. Unlike the Superior Court, it held that direct jurisdiction applied because the Branch’s services were integral to its grain-elevator clients, which could not operate during a strike. Alternatively, it agreed that derivative jurisdiction applied because the evidence showed the Branch was integrated into Viterra.

III. Analysis

paras. 28–120

Quebec argues that the lower decisions erred. Since SGS does not operate the elevators, direct jurisdiction is unavailable, and the evidence does not show that the Branch is functionally distinct or that SGS as a whole or the Division is integrated into Viterra. SGS responds that the findings establish the Branch’s functional distinctiveness and that the elevators continuously rely on its inspection services. It submits that either direct or derivative jurisdiction may apply. The appeal therefore asks whether the Montréal Branch is functionally distinct, whether direct federal jurisdiction applies, and whether derivative federal jurisdiction applies.

A. Standard of Review
para. 31

Constitutional questions concerning the division of powers are reviewed for correctness on judicial review from a tribunal, under Vavilov. Purely factual findings receive substantial deference, but inferences drawn from those findings and applied to constitutional tests are also reviewed for correctness. Accordingly, whether the Montréal Branch is a functionally discrete unit and whether direct or derivative federal jurisdiction applies are correctness questions.

B. Labour Relations and the Division of Powers
paras. 32–39
(1) Labour Is Presumptively a Matter of Provincial Jurisdiction
paras. 32–35

Labour relations presumptively fall within provincial jurisdiction over property and civil rights under s. 92(13) of the Constitution Act, 1867. The presumption may be displaced in exceptional circumstances through interjurisdictional immunity. Parliament has jurisdiction over labour relations connected with federal works and undertakings because regulating working conditions is essential to their management and operation. Tessier establishes two categories: direct jurisdiction, where an entity owns, manages, controls or operates a federal work or undertaking; and derivative jurisdiction, where an entity’s normal activities are integral to one or more federal works or undertakings and significant to the entity itself.

(2) The Declaratory Power Under Section 92(10)(c) of the Constitution Act, 1867
paras. 36–39

Section 92(10)(c) permits Parliament to declare works to be for the general advantage of Canada, thereby bringing them within exclusive federal jurisdiction. The power is extraordinary and must be used with restraint. Federal authority extends to the work as a functioning unit, including its operation and management, and to the physical parts and operational aspects that make it specifically federal. Matters merely touching the work without a sufficiently close connection remain provincial. The provision therefore does not confer plenary jurisdiction over everything associated with a declared work.

C. The Legal Framework
paras. 40–64

Tessier and earlier cases establish a three-stage framework. The decision-maker first identifies the entity and its essential operational nature; if it is a unit within a larger organization, the unit must be functionally distinct. The decision-maker then asks whether direct or derivative jurisdiction applies. Earlier cases’ overlapping factors sometimes obscure which doctrine they address, producing confusion in the lower decisions. The framework separates the preliminary characterization inquiry from the distinct tests for direct and derivative jurisdiction.

(1) Step 1: Identify the Entity and Its Essential Operational Nature
paras. 42–52

The first step is to identify the entity—an entire organization or a discrete unit—and assess its essential operational nature by examining its ordinary work, operations and daily activities as a going concern. The analysis must identify a related federal work or undertaking; without one, it fails. A work is a physical structure, while an undertaking is the arrangement of operations supporting federally regulated activities, including the operation of a federal work. A unit within a larger organization may be separately characterized only if it is functionally distinct; an indivisible operation cannot be artificially divided. Functional distinctiveness depends on the unit’s dominant character and services, not corporate labels or geography alone. Relevant, non-exhaustive factors include employees’ tasks, their contact with other units, the management and operational environment, location, and the unit’s role in the organization. The inquiry is flexible, and similar services may still be functionally distinct where the unit can be separated without artificial division.

(2) Step 2: The Test for Direct Jurisdiction
paras. 53–56

Direct jurisdiction is reserved for entities directly operating a federal work or undertaking and extends to employees supporting its management and operation. Where an entity operates both federal and provincial works, its normal or habitual activities must be dedicated to the federal work; otherwise the provincial presumption remains. Ontario Hydro concerned the operator’s own employees at its nuclear facilities. The Court of Appeal improperly treated services that are necessary or essential to a federal work as sufficient for direct jurisdiction, thereby importing derivative jurisdiction’s integration test. Direct jurisdiction has only been applied where the employees are employed by an entity that owns, manages, controls or otherwise operates the federal work.

(3) Step 3: The Test for Derivative Jurisdiction
paras. 57–64

Derivative jurisdiction may apply to a third-party service provider where its services are vital, essential or integral to the core operation of one or more federal works or undertakings and significant to the provider itself. The flexible inquiry considers physical and operational connection, corporate interrelationship and the importance of the employees’ work. Integration requires an ongoing relationship such that the federal undertaking could not operate without the services; temporary or exceptional relationships are insufficient. The services must form the provider’s principal or predominant activity, though no fixed percentage is required. The analysis may consider one or several federal works, provided the evidence establishes integration and identifies discrete federal works rather than an ill-defined industry. The resulting framework requires identification of the entity and its functional distinctiveness, followed by the direct and derivative tests.

D. Application
paras. 65–120
(1) The Montréal Branch and Its Essential Operational Nature
paras. 65–81

The Montréal Branch’s normal activities are specialized grain inspection and grading. Inspectors sample grain, conduct tests, inspect and seal silos, while graders analyse samples and assign grades under Commission standards; results are sent to clients and used for compliance certificates. About 90 percent of the Branch’s time is spent serving six Quebec grain elevators, all declared federal works. The Tribunal properly found the Agriculture and Agri-Food Division functionally distinct from SGS because it has separate finances, infrastructure, offices and employees, with no interdependence among divisions. The Montréal Branch is also sufficiently distinct from the other branches. Unlike them, it focuses on grain handling, has specialized employees, serves Quebec elevators exclusively within the Division, and has provided longstanding services to Viterra. It has its own manager, finances, infrastructure, offices and dedicated laboratories, and operates independently. The fact that other branches perform similar services elsewhere does not prevent separation. There is no artificial division because no comparable inspectors and graders work elsewhere in Quebec. The 14 employees may therefore be considered separately.

(2) The Montréal Branch Does Not Meet the Test for Direct Jurisdiction
paras. 82–90

The Tribunal held that direct jurisdiction did not apply, while the Court of Appeal held that it did. Karakatsanis J. agrees with the Attorney General of Quebec that the Court of Appeal conflated direct and derivative jurisdiction by treating integrated or functionally necessary services as sufficient. Ontario Hydro concerned the operator’s own employees and facilities, not an independent contractor. Direct jurisdiction applies only where the employer operates the federal work. SGS neither owns, manages, controls nor operates the grain elevators; it provides authorized third-party inspection services under the Canada Grain Act. SGS and the elevator operators also do not form one undertaking because they share no common management, control or direction. The Branch is therefore connected to, but does not operate, the declared works, and direct jurisdiction does not apply.

(3) The Montréal Branch Falls Under Derivative Federal Jurisdiction
paras. 91–120

Derivative jurisdiction applies because the Branch’s services are vital to Viterra and the other five Quebec grain elevators, and comprise a significant part of the Branch’s own operations. Grain must be sampled and analysed during loading, approximately every 2,000 metric tons, to monitor quality and permit immediate corrections. The Canada Grain Act requires inspection certificates, and elevators cannot perform the work without authorization and qualified personnel. Certificates are also necessary for domestic sales and help secure export certification; without them, grain cannot move. SGS is Viterra’s only provider, all such inspectors are in the Montréal Branch, and grain cannot move to or from Viterra without the Branch. Its employees work in Viterra’s laboratories and communicate with it about every 20 minutes. Viterra’s commercial activities are intertwined with elevator operation, so separate treatment is unnecessary. The Branch’s work is also integrated into the other five elevators through close physical and operational connections and the regulated, consistent nature of the services. Ninety percent of the Branch’s services concern the six federal elevators, and Viterra’s work is predominant. No fixed 80-percent threshold is required. The analysis may consider several individually declared federal works; Stevedores supports that approach, while Central Western rejects only vague, catch-all undertakings. The Branch is a functionally discrete unit devoted principally to federal works, so derivative jurisdiction applies.

IV. Conclusion

paras. 121–122

The Quebec Labour Code does not apply to the bargaining unit because its employees fall within derivative federal jurisdiction connected with works declared to be for the general advantage of Canada under s. 92(10)(c) of the Constitution Act, 1867. The courts below correctly held that the Tribunal lacked jurisdiction over the certification application. Karakatsanis J. would dismiss the appeal with costs.

Reasons of Kasirer J.

paras. 123–237

I. Overview

paras. 123–135

Kasirer J. would allow the appeal, set aside the lower-court judgments, quash the Tribunal’s decision and declare that certification of the SGS employees is governed by the Quebec Labour Code. The issue is whether Parliament’s declaration under s. 92(10)(c) of the Constitution Act, 1867, and s. 55(1) of the Canada Grain Act, covering grain elevators as works for Canada’s general advantage, extends to 14 SGS employees in Montreal. He concludes that it gives Parliament neither direct nor derivative authority over SGS’s labour relations. Labour relations presumptively fall within provincial jurisdiction, and the declaration over a work does not confer plenary authority over the broader grain trade or third-party service providers. Direct jurisdiction covers operation of the declared work; derivative jurisdiction requires functional integration assessed from both undertakings’ perspectives, including that the relevant service be predominant in the provincial undertaking’s activities. SGS operates neither an elevator nor an undertaking functionally integrated with Viterra. A broader approach would undermine federalism and improperly enlarge federal labour jurisdiction.

II. Background

paras. 136–142

Section 55(1) of the Canada Grain Act declares grain elevators in Canada subject to Parliament, while s. 2 identifies elevators in the Western and Eastern Divisions, including those along specified navigable waters and the St. Lawrence River. The Act regulates weighing and inspection, requiring terminal-elevator operators to perform those functions unless exempted, but permitting them to retain an authorized third party at the request of the person delivering the grain or the receiving elevator. SGS is one of five authorized providers. Elevator operators such as Viterra retain SGS both to meet statutory requirements and for commercial purposes connected with buying, selling and exporting grain. Those purposes include assessing value, directing sales and transport, monitoring quality and avoiding costly non-compliant exports. Commission officials still conduct official weighing and inspection and issue certificates permitting export, but operators obtain SGS’s faster, independent and sometimes contractually required testing and certification.

III. Issues on Appeal

para. 143

The Attorney General of Quebec advances two submissions: Parliament’s authority does not extend to SGS’s labour relations through direct jurisdiction, and it does not extend through derivative jurisdiction.

IV. Analysis

paras. 144–202

The appeal concerns the scope of federal labour jurisdiction arising from Parliament’s declaration of grain elevators as works under s. 55(1) of the Canada Grain Act. Kasirer J. concludes that neither direct nor derivative federal jurisdiction applies to SGS.

A. The Federal Declaratory Power Must Not Be Construed Beyond Its Inherent Limits
paras. 145–151

Section 92(10)(c), read with s. 91(29) of the Constitution Act, 1867, gives Parliament an exceptional power to declare a provincially situated work to be for Canada’s general advantage. Unlike s. 92(10)(a), it refers only to “works”, not undertakings, and that distinction limits federal authority. A declaration transfers the specified work to federal jurisdiction but does not sweep in every associated activity or allow Parliament to declare an undertaking or an entire industry federal. Courts generally review only whether the subject is a work and whether the declaration was made expressly by statute, not whether Parliament correctly judged the work advantageous to Canada. Because the power can substantially impair provincial legislative autonomy and has historically been used to avoid provincial labour legislation, “work” must be interpreted narrowly. Federal jurisdiction must be described consistently with federalism, a central constitutional principle requiring regard to the balance between federal and provincial interests. An interpretation covering all activities associated with a declared work would risk eviscerating provincial competence, particularly over labour relations.

B. Federal Jurisdiction Over Labour Relations Is a Limited Exception to the Presumptive Rule of Provincial Jurisdiction
paras. 152–157

Under Snider and subsequent decisions, labour relations fall presumptively within provincial jurisdiction over property and civil rights under s. 92(13), because employment and collective agreements are contractual relationships. Parliament has only secondary, incidental authority over labour relations where regulation is necessarily connected to a federal head of power; it has no freestanding or plenary labour jurisdiction. Such authority may arise under various powers, including postal services, banking, fisheries, aeronautics and the declaratory power, but remains an exception to exclusive provincial competence. In this context the recognized methods are direct and derivative jurisdiction. National importance, practical efficiency or the difficulty of dividing labour jurisdiction cannot independently support federal authority. Although Parliament declared grain elevators to be for Canada’s general advantage, that rationale does not bring every provincial undertaking contributing to them under federal labour law. Federalism permits overlapping jurisdiction and cooperation, while provincial laws of general application may continue to govern associated undertakings.

C. The Applicability of Direct Jurisdiction to Federal Works
paras. 158–174

The Court of Appeal treated SGS’s services as functionally necessary and essential to elevator operations and therefore within direct federal jurisdiction. Kasirer J. agrees with the appellant that this imports the integration analysis belonging to derivative jurisdiction. Direct and derivative jurisdiction are distinct exceptions, and the party asserting federal jurisdiction bears the burden of establishing the applicable one.

(1) Parliament Exercises Its Declaratory Power Over Works, Not Undertakings
paras. 160–164

Section 92(10)(c)’s omission of “undertakings”, contrasted with s. 92(10)(a), limits the declaratory power to works. A work is a physical, fixed and determinate thing; an undertaking is an organized arrangement of resources for pursuing activities. The declaration must therefore be interpreted first to identify the particular works it covers. Ontario Hydro establishes that a declaration reaches beyond a work’s physical shell to its functional operation, including some control over activities occurring on or connected with it. That authority can extend to the undertaking operating the work, because control over its uses is necessary to make federal jurisdiction effective. But jurisdiction over the operator flows from jurisdiction over the declared work and its uses; it is not an independent federal jurisdiction over the undertaking itself. The distinction preserves the declaratory power’s constitutional limits.

(2) Direct Jurisdiction Over Labour Relations Arises Through the Operation of a Federal Work
paras. 165–174

For a declared work, direct federal labour jurisdiction extends only to the undertaking operating that work. Physical works do not themselves have labour relations, so the relevant question is whether the undertaking’s normal or habitual activities consist of operating a federal work. In the grain-elevator context, the Act defines elevators by their purposes of receiving, handling, storing, cleaning and treating grain, and requires compliant facilities. An undertaking whose regular activities operate such an elevator is federal, and its labour relations fall within federal jurisdiction. The Court of Appeal erred by treating integration as relevant to direct jurisdiction, by asking whether SGS’s services were functionally necessary or essential rather than examining SGS’s own operational nature, and by relying on the broader federal regulation of grain. Important participation in federally regulated activities does not itself make an undertaking federal. Direct jurisdiction attaches to the elevator and the undertaking operating it; SGS operates none of the six elevators at issue. The inquiry begins with the statutory declaration and asks whether the undertaking itself operates a declared work.

D. Derivative Jurisdiction Is Limited to Provincial Undertakings That Lose Their Distinct Character by Integration With Federal Undertakings
paras. 175–202

Derivative jurisdiction may bring a provincial undertaking under federal labour law where its essential operational nature makes it integral to a federal undertaking. The governing test is functional integration, not merely physical connection, commercial benefit or the importance of the service. The provincial undertaking must lose its distinct character and effectively function as part of the federal undertaking. Northern Telecom identifies factors including the provincial undertaking’s general nature, the corporate relationship, the importance of the employees’ work and the physical and operational connection. Tessier requires the relationship to be assessed from both perspectives: the federal undertaking must significantly depend on the service, and the service must be predominant in the provincial undertaking’s overall activities. Both conditions must be satisfied; an important or essential contribution alone is insufficient. In the declaratory-power context the jurisdiction is “doubly derivative”, because it extends from the declared work to its operator and then to a provincial service provider. The analysis must concern a single identifiable federal undertaking, not an agglomeration of works. A proposed discrete employee unit is not a preliminary issue or independent test; its distinctness results from integration with the federal undertaking. The same two-perspectives inquiry applies whether the unit or the provincial undertaking as a whole is considered. There is no residual basis, including interjurisdictional immunity, for federal labour jurisdiction when direct and derivative tests fail. These strict criteria protect provincial jurisdiction and prevent a declaration over elevators from becoming authority over the grain trade.

V. Application

paras. 203–236

Constitutional questions are reviewed for correctness, although factual findings receive deference unless they reflect errors of law. Kasirer J. concludes that the declaration does not support federal labour jurisdiction over the SGS employees. The Court of Appeal used the wrong direct-jurisdiction test by asking whether SGS supplied a functionally necessary and essential service rather than whether SGS operated a declared elevator. It also used the wrong derivative-jurisdiction standard by failing to determine whether SGS had lost its distinct identity through functional integration with a single federal undertaking, assessed from both perspectives. The facts that the 14 employees devoted 90 percent of their aggregate time to six elevators and that SGS held 80 percent of Canada’s grain-testing market did not establish such integration. The same result follows whether SGS, its Agriculture and Food Division or its Montreal branch is treated as the provincial undertaking.

A. Labour Relations of the SGS Employees in Question Do Not Fall Within Direct Federal Jurisdiction
paras. 206–214

The declaration covers grain elevators and the undertakings operating them, not the grain trade generally or every service involved in it. SGS is not an operator under the Canada Grain Act: it possesses none of the elevators and does not receive, store or load grain as an elevator operator does. The 2012 amendments created a regulated role for independent third-party inspectors, while retaining official inspection and export certification within the Canadian Grain Commission. SGS’s certificates assist grain movement but are issued independently, in its own name, and are not the official certificates required for export. Its contractual relationship with elevator operators results from their choice among authorized providers, and compliance with Commission standards does not make SGS an operator. Inspection, analysis, certification and quality-control services remain provincial activities. Extending the declaration to them would distort “works” under s. 92(10)(c) and improperly encompass the grain trade. SGS is therefore a provincial undertaking whose labour relations do not fall within direct federal jurisdiction.

B. Labour Relations of the SGS Employees in Question Do Not Fall Within Derivative Federal Jurisdiction
paras. 215–236

Derivative jurisdiction requires SGS to be functionally integrated with one federal undertaking so that SGS loses its distinct identity. The relevant federal undertaking is Viterra’s operation of the Montreal terminal, not the six Quebec elevators collectively. Those elevators are operated independently by rival companies, and the statutory reference to all elevators collectively and separately does not alter the functional-integration test. Although the 14 employees devoted 90 percent of their time collectively to the six terminals, the record did not establish the proportion attributable to Viterra. Viterra could also replace SGS with one of four competing providers, and SGS’s work served Viterra’s separate commercial activities of buying, selling and exporting grain as well as elevator operations. The federal interest is confined to the declared work, principally handling and storing grain, not broader grain-trade activities. From SGS’s perspective, Viterra represented only a small part of SGS’s national operations, a modest part of its Agriculture and Food Division’s activities, and an unquantified part of the Montreal branch’s work. The employees rotated among clients and locations, had no permanent presence at Viterra and did not devote the exclusive or principal part of their activities to it. The record therefore did not show mutual dependence, functional integration or that the branch was a functionally discrete unit subsumed into Viterra. SGS’s distinct identity was, in fact, important to the independent certification relied on by international purchasers. Derivative jurisdiction consequently does not apply, and the employees fall within provincial jurisdiction.

VI. Disposition

para. 237

Kasirer J. would allow the appeal with costs, set aside the Superior Court and Court of Appeal judgments, quash the Tribunal’s decision, grant judicial review and declare that the Quebec Labour Code applies to the certification petition. The disposition also records that the appeal was dismissed with costs, with Wagner C.J. and Côté, Kasirer and O’Bonsawin JJ. dissenting.

The Court’s text (PDF)

The official version is published in the Supreme Court Reports (S.C.R.).

The hearing (video and audio)

The oral arguments, recorded by the Supreme Court of Canada. Video or audio, in English, French or the original language, on the Court’s website.

Generated by AI from public documents. Not legal advice; check the source.

Unofficial reproduction. The official version of judgments is published in the Supreme Court Reports (S.C.R.). Summaries are Agora’s and form no part of the Court’s reasons.